MoM Awards - Rnd 5 - Dunfermline Athletic (h)

[Radford 72]

Chris Millar for at least looking semi-fit and looking like he actually cared.

[sconesjfc]

MoM taking the piss?

[MUZZ]

millar as well. best out of a very bad bunch.

[Rodgers]

james

defence looked crap but thought he held it together, the best he could

[Watty]

Millar for me, runs all day and can play football, just a pity 90% of his team mate did not do either today.

[Ali91]

milne. millar played well first half imo but drifted out of it in the second.

[saint_markperth]

It was between millar and smith for me, millar had quite a few wayward passes so smith for me

[Mr Spoons]

Savo for me - at least he looked interested.

[scotty gordon]

MoM hahahahaha

[Das Rave]

Millar for me, only one who really looked interested in midfield. just ahead of smith, who put in a lot of good crosses that weren't attacked.

[SJC]

Peaso MOM by default.

He didn't make any awful mistakes or cost us a goal, unlike most of the other players.

[Pablo]

No vote today, none of them deserve it. I know MoM is in the context of the game itself but even though Savo and Millar ran around more than the others I refuse to vote on that garbage.

[Mr_Plow]

Hmm, Millar was ok, faded a bit in the second half. Probably give it to Savo.

[Dennistoun Saint]

Savo, if one has to be awarded.

[templeofsaints]

Smith for me - at least he got forward and tried to create things. Only Savo came close for effort.

[Dylan-Saints]

the MoM for us was the final whistle

[SaintSam1884]

The sponsors gave it to Gary Irvine. Although I hear todays sponsors were Dunfermline fans and that it was a bit of a 'piss take'. Shameful.

I thought Millar, James and Savo played well today but not well enough to earn a vote of this kind. Won't be voting this week.

[+Super Trooper+]

milne. millar played well first half imo but drifted out of it in the second.

Spot on mate. Had to go for savo for his effort and an overall gutsy performance.

[Burghsaintee]

Smith for me - at least he got forward and tried to create things. Only Savo came close for effort.

Agree

[Bruno Strasser]

MoM taking the piss?

:cry: Afraid I have to agree and pass on this one - unless we are going to have the chance to vote for a Dunfermline Player.

[Brian Potter]

We need to get behind Mclean! Im giving him a season before I join the calls for him to never play again!

He gets my vote

[slf]

We need to get behind Mclean! Im giving him a season before I join the calls for him to never play again!

He gets my vote

thats the spirit me too

[Southpaw]

Millar for me, although the team managed to drag him down as the game went on.

[mainstand]

The sponsors gave it to Gary Irvine. Although I hear todays sponsors were Dunfermline fans and that it was a bit of a 'piss take'. Shameful.

I thought Millar, James and Savo played well today but not well enough to earn a vote of this kind. Won't be voting this week.

I thought he played okay today!

[Ray Blair]

james

defence looked crap but thought he held it together, the best he could



Are you serious?Possibly Millar but it was a poor showing generally

[Oldmuirton]

Chris Millar was the only man who earned his wages today in my opinion,although Savo at least tried.

[auld reekie saint]

I thought Kevin James has a decent game so he gets my vote.Millar and Savo both get pass marks.
The rest of the team were utter mince.

[slf]

i give that ponce on the tannoy pass marks for playing liquidator again.

[sjm89]

Holmes for me won his fair share in the air, held the ball the ball up well think we lacked that after half time.

[sconesjfc]

We need to get behind Mclean! Im giving him a season before I join the calls for him to never play again!

He gets my vote

Why? He is shite, get him to ****, he brings nothing to this team.

[The ghost of Jim Morton]

Savo.At least he looked a bit like he cared.

I know it's a forum and there are always going to be different opinions but how any person can give a vote to the keeper or Kevin James is beyond me.
Both were SHITE,really shite.Fuxake how can you give a MOM award to anybody from a defence that lost three goals.:oops:

[SaintSam1884]

I thought he played okay today!

Gary Irvine? Fair enough he wasn't flying into tackles and completely missing them, but he wasn't doing much else by way of defending either. I like Irvine, I know he can be a good player, but I'd have Anderson in there as soon as possible to tighten that defence up. Irvine is good at supporting the right midfield, but we don't need another player getting forward as much as we need to stop leaking so many goals. We need Irvine to stay back, stay in position and defend well. He's doing none of that. I lost count of the number of times Rutkiewicz had to move out of the centre of defence today because Irvine was nowhere to be seen. He was by no means the worst player today but I think Anderson could do a better job defensively.

[Cagey]

Actually think the score would have been even more embarassing if it hadn`t been for James who along with Savo & Millar were the only guys in the team who looked interested today. If the rest put in half the effort that Savo did we may have at least competed so he is my MoM.

[ancientsaint]

Chris Millar -once again- he looks our best player week in week out-splays passes into attacking areas-some intercepted and most create chances-even if its from side to side.

As for the young keeper - he is learning the hard way and to be honest it needs the 10 guys in front of him to get the ball away before it reaches him.

like to see us play a sweeper in behind the back four.

[SJC]

We don't have a season to waste on finding out if McLean is a good keeper or not, 2 games to improve or drop him for Main.

[struthy]

I canny believe some people have used their vote to back McLean, i personnaly voted for Peso as he was the only one that probably could do no wrong - the rest of the team were absolutely shocking yesterday!!!!!

[THE LARK SAINT]

Iknowe others dont agree but i thought the two kevs were ok today but they have no confidence in a keeper who has no confidence in him self, in all the years i have watched saints(40 odd) i have never seen a keeper more scared to come of his line.He has to be dropped and get some coaching and confidence before he will be no 1 keeper, only when main is back will we see how good the two kevs are.As for mom it is really hard when we were so bad only four players deserve a mention in my book they are two kevs , savo and millar, , as ive said some will not agree(ghostie) but for me big kev was solid and might have been worse without him, so he shades it over millar who faded away in second half , and savo who never gave up.

[Jags Ya Bas!]

Gary Irvine? Fair enough he wasn't flying into tackles and completely missing them, but he wasn't doing much else by way of defending either.
How do you know?! :neutral:

[Kevin]

Peaso MOM by default.

He didn't make any awful mistakes or cost us a goal, unlike most of the other players.

That's because he didn't touch the ball

[St Mikey]

james

defence looked crap but thought he held it together, the best he could


ARE YOU AN ALCOHOLIC OR JUST DRUNK WHEN YOU TYPED THIS?!?!?!?!

James was gash and double gash. Everytime the ball went into our half he, AGAIN AND AGAIN, makes it his mission to header every ball. He was caught in possession and past the ball as it came forward the whole game. Even at free-kicks and corners EVERY ball went to him, then he moaned like a little girl when he got no-where near the ball. Best dropping him and also Sheerin. Simply not good enough. Sheerin hit too many hospital passes all game and was faster running off for the substitute than anywhere else the whole game

MOM - No

Liability - Defo Yes

I take MOM as achieving higher than at least 7/10 for the game. Nobody even attained a 6/10. The best out of a very very very bad bunch was McCaffrey - thought he warmed up really well.

[sign dave]

dan smith for me,

he chased the ball with lots of pace at times, and made forward runs in simmilar fasion to the way stanic did although his crossing wasnt his strong point


what was it with the crossing today? did we miss the likes of hardie to head the ball or were they all bad balls?

should have had peaso on from start at expense of craig, can only say this after the game, before i would have started craig

[Saint Chaz]

Gave it to Savo just for the amount of effort he put in, kind of summed up our day the chance he missed late on. Didn't really matter by that stage anyway.

[Lost Son of Fairbairn]

Toss up between the 2 subs that didnt play Main or McCaffrey ... says it all ! Their performance during a warm up was very professional !

[Zimmerman]

Millar

[stanley saint]

someone in a pars shirt or the officals