MoM Awards - Rnd 24 - Partick Thistle (a)

[Radford 72]

Gary Irvine for me.

[Macarius]

Was not at the game, but I'm giving Gary Irvine a vote since he's one of my favoured player and rarely gets any recognition or praise. He also headed a goal bound shot off the line today so have to give it to him. Good too see him getting some praise.

[Saintly Child]

Giving it to Gary Irvine just ahead of the rest of the defenders. As said before he never gets the recognition he deserves.

Well Done Gary you played a blinder.

[Broon]

Gary Irvine was outstanding today. Genius performance.

[Saline Saint]

Easily Irvine for me,header off the line which saved us from defeat,great tackling all over the field one in particular in the fist half in the left back position when Hanlon was posted missing.Got booked for a dive but the ref was a joke as per usual.

[templeofsaints]

Gary "Panther" Irvine. Hanlon and Caff were solid and Craig did well despite playing through the bloody pain barrier again.

[Mr_Plow]

Was not at the game, but I'm giving Gary Irvine a vote since he's one of my favoured player and rarely gets any recognition or praise. He also headed a goal bound shot off the line today so have to give it to him. Good too see him getting some praise.

If you weren't there then why vote?

[Scobby_SJFC]

I wasnt that impressed with Gary irvine, sorry guys good header off the line but still is not the player he has been for us does not look confident

Vote for me went to rusty!!

[Perth-Saint]

Morris for me.

[perth_saintee12]

Irvine had a good game, better than he has had in recent weeks.

[The ghost of Jim Morton]

No contest today.This is gonna be the most convincing MOM award of the whole season.

GARY IRVINE.

[Mike180279]

I have went for Gary Irvine. I didnt think he had an o/s game but that clearance could well be massive for us. Puzzled why he went down when he got booked, think the bigger advantage would have been staying on his feet, and yes it looked a clear dive from where I was despite the shocked reaction around me.

Jody was first class again.

[saintj]

i thought it was a dive but it looked like the ball was gettin away from him

[O'Rourke]

Delighted to see Gary Irvine getting the vote. I hope he can keep up such a high level of performance on a consistent basis as he has had his share of stick on here.

Well done Gaz.

[Dave H]

many good first half performances, eclipsed by the second half but Irvine won us a point :)

[Macarius]

If you weren't there then why vote?

If you had bothered to read my post you would understand why, but since you clearly didn't i'll leave it too you to give it another skim over.

[Ali91]

If you had bothered to read my post you would understand why, but since you clearly didn't i'll leave it too you to give it another skim over.

I read your post and i still think it is ridiculous that you voted. If everyone who never went voted for their favourite player then this MotM thing would be a farce.

[101 Saint]

I wasnt that impressed with Gary irvine, sorry guys good header off the line but still is not the player he has been for us does not look confident

Vote for me went to rusty!!

:?

Never usually vote on these, but Irvine won a point today on behalf of St Johnstone FC. I vote 4 Gaz - sound like a political issue in Ukraine:cool:

[101 Saint]

Ok, we'll just call up Gary Irvine and future and tell him not to head goal bound shots off the line because it would be a farce as well.

Get a ****ing grip.
See Ali91, that's what we need on here; logic and reasoned debate.

Moon is my favourite, so I'll vote for him next week.

[Mr_Plow]

Ok, we'll just call up Gary Irvine and future and tell him not to head goal bound shots off the line because it would be a farce as well.

Get a ****ing grip.

The reason for this thread is to vote on people you think merit being MOM on the basis that you attended the match (or if you watched it on TV etc). Voting for a player because he's your favourite or because you feel he hasn't received recognition of late is missing the point.

I wasn't at the game but I'm hardly going to vote for anyone based on news reports or other fans' opinions.

[Ali91]

To get back on topic i voted Irvine as i was at the game and know how he played.

[saintj]

Ok, we'll just call up Gary Irvine and future and tell him not to head goal bound shots off the line because it would be a farce as well.

Get a ****ing grip.

while your on the phone tell homer to stop scorin as well .... :)

[101 Saint]

while your on the phone tell homer to stop scorin as well .... :)

Didn't he make that call in Autumn!

[patsy]

Was not at the game, but I'm giving Gary Irvine a vote since he's one of my favoured player and rarely gets any recognition or praise. He also headed a goal bound shot off the line today so have to give it to him. Good too see him getting some praise.

I never made the game today either but on a whole this season i think irvine has been poor he tucks into the centre far too much

[saintj]

Didn't he make that call in Autumn!

haha quite possibly

[saintj]

I never made the game today either but on a whole this season i think irvine has been poor he tucks into the centre far too much

apart from at the start of the season irvine has been quite good for us

[tbaysaint]

I voted for gary for winning us that point to be honest

Although Sammy did lighten up the game when he came on

[The ghost of Jim Morton]

Well what do you expect, you've been mouthing off at me all night.

Calm doon ffs....:shock:

[SJC]

Oh the irony

Abused in another thread for denouncing Jody Morris, then told to watch him play by two people who don't go to the games

Shame on you both

Irvine was man of the match, he's improved a lot and is one of the most important players in the team

[patsy]

Oh the irony

Abused in another thread for denouncing Jody Morris, then told to watch him play by two people who don't go to the games

Shame on you both

Irvine was man of the match, he's improved a lot and is one of the most important players in the team

who are the 2 people that dont go to the games?

[saintj]

Oh the irony

Abused in another thread for denouncing Jody Morris, then told to watch him play by two people who don't go to the games

Shame on you both

Irvine was man of the match, he's improved a lot and is one of the most important players in the team

i do hope that wasnt aimed at me, if it is you are as ignorant as you sound

[The ghost of Jim Morton]

Apparently me.

And you calm down Ghostie. You chip pan dodging jacobite swine filled ghost of a thousand christmases cast into the suuuuunshiiiiiiiiiiiiine.

I'm a picture of tranquilitty and calm....:wink:http://www.behavioradvisor.com/relaxed.jpg

[saintj]

i can see the striking resemblance mr ghost :)

[Broon]

Private messages for this nonsense. Back to the topic. Gary Irvine - the Cafu of SD1.

[Mike180279]

Superb Write up in the News of the World for him too something about the players saying they wouldnt be able to stop it with their hands......

[Tranmere Saintee]

Thanks children for giving me all this extra work on a Sunday morning - please refrain from this pathetic name calling in future and please read the forum rules.:mad:

Apologies for the thread now looking a bit disjointed, but have tried to remove most of the nonsense and leave it readable.

If I have accidentally removed any sensible posts, again please accept my apologies.

[SingaporeSaint]

I would like to point out that voting for MoM is for people who have actually seen the game whether by tv or actual attendance. Us overseas supporters....yes you can support a team from afar ; ) very much appreciate listening to fellow supporters views on the match. Voting on MoM without actually seeing the game seems silly to me ? Other opinions on this point are very welcome.

The apologies from Tranmere Saint for removing my post are very much accepted but Macarius please see sense in what I say. If the overwhelming feeling is that my opinion is shit, then tbh, I will still refrain from voting.

[SingaporeSaint]

Was not at the game, but I'm giving Gary Irvine a vote since he's one of my favoured player and rarely gets any recognition or praise. He also headed a goal bound shot off the line today so have to give it to him. Good too see him getting some praise.

This is what prompted me to make comment and you TS for removing my post, read the rules ; )

[Macarius]

Since Gary Irvine is winning the MOTM award by a clear distance. You can't say I'm wrong.

[dave mc]

Irvine already was getting my vote before that goal-line clearance.As someone said he had a great interception covering Hanlon in the first half,tackled well all day,then had a back post header almost from under the bar,with two jags looking to score.Mention for Caff,who was brilliant at reading the game,and covering for all the others when needed.

[monkfish]

Was not at the game, but I'm giving Gary Irvine a vote since he's one of my favoured player and rarely gets any recognition or praise. He also headed a goal bound shot off the line today so have to give it to him. Good too see him getting some praise.

Saintee Brian Gate 2!

Irvine for me, he would of deserved it even without the goal line clearance. Maybe his 'dive' might have soured it, but you couldn't see it from where we were sitting and given some of the refs decisions I wouldn't be surprised if he got that one wrong as well.

[garydavidson]

superb, saved us on at least four occasions. solid display mr irvine.

[perth_saintee12]

Yeah he stood out as the best player for us at firhill.

[sjfcsean]

Gary Irvine, what a clearance.

[Mr Spoons]

Since Gary Irvine is winning the MOTM award by a clear distance. You can't say I'm wrong.

Sorry but we can!

How you think you can give a valid MOM vote to aplayer when you were not at the game defies belief! We had an issue a few years ago with folk (usually David Hannah fans) who would vote for their favourite player just to give them more points - regardless how they played.

Let's be quite clear about this: You can only vote for the MOM if you were at the game or (and I concede this reluctantly) you watched the WHOLE gamre on TV.

Have to say though, I admire your honesty!

[SingaporeSaint]

Sorry but we can!

How you think you can give a valid MOM vote to aplayer when you were not at the game defies belief! We had an issue a few years ago with folk (usually David Hannah fans) who would vote for their favourite player just to give them more points - regardless how they played.

Let's be quite clear about this: You can only vote for the MOM if you were at the game or (and people voting for I concede this reluctantly) you watched the WHOLE gamre on TV.

Have to say though, I admire your honesty!

Mr Spoons, why do you have "reluctance" on people voting after watching the game on TV. I was extremely excited being able to vote on WAP after watching last years' semi f against Rangers. I would argue that you get a better view of the game on TV and probably see more of the action. Not meaning to be argumentative btw.

[Mike180279]

Mr Spoons, why do you have "reluctance" on people voting after watching the game on TV. I was extremely excited being able to vote on WAP after watching last years' semi f against Rangers. I would argue that you get a better view of the game on TV and probably see more of the action. Not meaning to be argumentative btw.Agree and disagree. It is very easy to point out the man of the match if someone is having a stormer skinning players, scoring, goal scoring tackles etc. But quite often the man of the match could easily be the man blocking the runs, pulling a defender away from the ball etc the things that generally you dont see on the tv and only pick up in the after match analysis.

[Mr Spoons]

SingaporeSaint, Respect and completely understand your point! It's not often you will get to see a full Saints game on the telly and I can fully understand how estranged Saintees will enjoy joining in with the debate etc. So I suggest MOM awards only given by those at the game or who have watched a live game on telly. And that's all!

[The ghost of Jim Morton]

Has there ever been a more comprehensive result Radford ???...
75% is some going..

[The Inspiration]

I wasnt that impressed with Gary irvine, sorry guys good header off the line but still is not the player he has been for us does not look confident

Vote for me went to rusty!!

The amount of times irvine covered rusty was ridiculous! Caff had a nightmare and it seemed at one point that our back line consisted of only one player.

How you can say you weren't impressed with him is beyond me

[Broon]

Caff had a nightmare

:laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh:

Caff had a very good game. Nobody had a nightmare. Rusty was caught out of position a few times but nothing really serious.

[101 Saint]

:laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh:

Caff had a very good game. Nobody had a nightmare. Rusty was caught out of position a few times but nothing really serious.

It's serious when you're full back has to cover 5 times in the middle of the goal and both centrebacks are posted missing. Caff was dreadful in the second half.