Widge

Well that's simply not true at all, there was plenty of this especially in the away leg

Care to explain why exactly it's pathetic? Heaven forbid they didn't bother to consult you first to suit your agenda.

Seriously? Silly season in full flow. He'd have been on 30k a week previously.

You think you can base a decision on a players ability after 15 minutes? That's nearly the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Gary MacDonald played a decent 15 minutes at one point or another does that make him a good player?

Why would saints want to advertise who we're taking to? It's only serve to alert other teams to these players availability and if they're actually good, we'd be out bid. Im happy not knowing anything.

McHattie giving away 2 of the softest penalties ever was hilarious. Ref felt like he needed to even it up. Scobbie even got away with a punch on someone before going in goals.

Scougall has barely had a pre-season and has spent the last 2 weeks in Dubai on holiday. I doubt he's up to speed, let alone match fit, so I'd be amazed if he started. Wright will go with the players he knows and trusts and I suspect Scougall will get the last 20 or so if we need him.

Why would we not play Easton when he's managed to play 90 minutes already in pre-season and is clearly fit enough?

I'd take Ciftci in a heartbeat, as much as he's a sulking, moaner he's got talent. Plus he'd be too scared by Maclean to not try his hardest. The irony being im not sure he'd be an automatic first pick, but if played he's good for 10/15 goals a season which is what we need.

Whilst that's true, it's a significant amount to saints.

It's not like James Dayton is an unknown player in Scotland. He's a player who's played a lot of games up here and has quality to change a game. Yes he's an enigma and may go missing for half a season, but I'd much rather have a player like him on the bench than Coulson, who isn't good enough. We have no real left winger and nobody with pace and ability to produce magic. If it's the right deal and a straight swap with Coulson then I'd 100% take Dayton in that role. He'd give excellent cover and competiton for our other midfielders.

Well that's a stupid argument he's not even close really.

Good, we'd be making Dundee a worse team by doing this.

Spittal has talent, just a poor mentality and application on the pitch. Which Tommy Wright will batter out of him quickly enough. He can't be any worse than Coulson!!

He wouldn't make so many last ditch tackles if he was in the correct position in the first place. It's James McPake syndrome, these are the things fans notice and love, but compare to Steven Anderson who can defend properly, he rarely makes these tackles.