• Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by TheYellowBox

  1. TheYellowBox

    Scottish cup

    I don't. Say Celtic hump us in the 2 games before it, why in earth would any neutral watch. Premier sports sum up what is wrong with the tv deals. At every opportunity through this deal, they will show Rangers and Celtic.
  2. TheYellowBox

    Player Contracts + Transfers

    £100k is way too low for Kerr, but I worry that saints would accept a figure which would still be a way below his real value. How saints handle this will in part determine future deals. Utd and hibs both showed that by getting good value for one player has a positive on what follows. For me, approaching £2m, with a 20% sell on would be fair. If he signs a new deal, I'd expect that Tommy will make clear to Jason that he will not stand in his way if a fair deal comes in for him. Still, I think he should be aiming higher than Barnsley. Not a slight on them as such, but he's better than league 1.
  3. TheYellowBox

    Player Contracts + Transfers

    Agree, the Swanson money was over and above, but maybe with Scougall potentially going, Nydham away and the likelihood of a relegation reduced then a bit of a freeing up of wages could happen. Of course though, if we want to offer new contracts to Watt, Kerr etc, you'd assume that would be more expensive. Unfortunately, despite the great football being played, the crowds haven't responded to give more cash.
  4. TheYellowBox

    Player Contracts + Transfers

    Could you imagine though a Saints team containing a fit O'Halloran, Swanson, Kennedy and Wright! That would give any opposition the utter fear. Each one could rip a team wide open, but 4 or them!! Not sure you'd get them all in the same side, but would love to see that. I'd give MOH a deal personally. Still young enough and like many before, realises what he has here vs chasing the money etc. Might also persuade Watt to stay. Genuinely the most talented saints team I've ever seen and could get even better.
  5. TheYellowBox

    Player Contracts + Transfers

    The wages from Scougall will allow for the signing of another quality player. I wouldn't be surprised if he's looking at a striker. Kane hasn't developed as I think Tommy would have hoped and we are lacking a goalscorer. Might see another couple moved out over and above that already announced. For me, I'd push the boat out and spend a decent fee on someone like shankland.
  6. TheYellowBox

    Top 10 complete Saints marketing fails..

    He's referring to the Rangers collapse and aftermath, I think.... That or it is meant to say OS in relation to the website? Marketing has been pretty poor, but I do think it is getting better. So much more potential there. As pointed out, the big missed opportunity post cup win is the benchmark. Yet to see it in the flesh, but the GS Brown advert on the north stand could be a late entry. The facade of the stadium is looking poor, so sticking a new sign on top not the best look. The wee red squares on the end bits annoy me every week, disproportionately so!
  7. TheYellowBox

    Zander Clark

    I think the defence as a whole look really strong at the moment. If you'd have said 2-3 years ago that we'd have Anderson and Easton out injured and Mannus gone, most fans would fear the worst, but Tanser has really come into a game and Clark and Kerr are getting better every game. Even better that they are a product of the saints youth system. Out of interest, how long is Clark tied town for? Can see some interest in him in January and the Summer, with the obvious imediate call up if he Does move.
  8. TheYellowBox

    Saints v Kilmarnock 24/11/18 League Game 14

    Totally agree. Thought Killie looked good today and are a decent striker away from being a top side, although, Kerr was immense against what they did have. I don't think I remember anyone getting by him or him not winning the first ball. I think Tommys logic for bringing Kane on was to chase them down so we didn't loose the game, rather than going to win it. Swanson was injured after his first touch, so really should have come off. Wotherspoon had the best game I've seen him have in a while, although looked dead on his feet at the end. Good point for both teams, similar set ups and standard, so can see both battling it out for a top 6 spot or both being in top 6.
  9. TheYellowBox

    Scottish Football

    Rather than clog up a match thread, what's folks views of Scottish Football as a whole and in what direction should it go? For me, I'd try a variation of summer football. I'd also bring in rules around youth development. Something along the lines that x% must have come from youth set up or at least have been involved with a Scottish youth set up. If say for example we sign a young player who came through the youths at Livingston, we wouldn't be penalised. As a country, we will never be able to retain our best talent, but what we can do is ensure that we give the clubs that develop them an advantage. If a club signs a foreign player, a % of the fee must go to a central pot that provides support to players released. E.g. Celtic spend £5m on a player, 5% or £250k goes to the SPL and is used as a cushion to players who are released as youths. I'd require a more even split of prize funds. Stern rules around club ownership.
  10. As a season ticket holder who didn't go yesterday, I genuinely didn't feel like I missed out tbh. I couldn't make it, but I suspect there will have been a few put off by the absolute horror show of our last home game. Performances aside, I think the problem is more fundamental, the whole set up is incredibly stale. Yes there is good stuff for kids, but not sure that entices many new fans. Going to McD is absolutely no different than it was 20 years ago. Bizarrely, the issue with saints is that there is no need for fans to turn up. We're not in a relegation battle, pushing for an honour not fighting for the club's survival. It's all just a bit meh! What would be interesting is to know how many different saints fans attend each season. Is it c4,000 different fans picking and choosing games or the same 2,000 every week? I suspect the club has no idea tbh.
  11. TheYellowBox

    MOTM Game 14 Saints 0 v 6 Celtic

    Thought Wotherspoon and Tanser controlled the game........
  12. TheYellowBox

    Saints v Celtic sunday

    Agree with every word of this. Ando coming on made such a difference, not least on Kerr, who looked like he actually had some direction. Spoony shouldn't get back in the side and should be off in January TBH.
  13. TheYellowBox

    Is Scottish Football truly incompetent?

    Which makes it worse. IF they announced that they were to redevelop Hampden and it cost x million and to pay for it, they needed to hold all games there to pay for it, then Maybe, Maybe fans could get on board, but as you say, there is no plan. Maybe they are holding out for a 2030 WC bid and get it funded that way?
  14. TheYellowBox

    Is Scottish Football truly incompetent?

    What no journalist has asked, that I have seen, is why the police demanded Aberdeen v Rangers is played first?
  15. TheYellowBox

    Is Scottish Football truly incompetent?

    But they paid just £6m for hampden. That would be paid off over 4 full houses or one scotland qualifying campaign. Not to mention, ignoring that, from the £1m pa saving from not renting it. Get it is the spfl and not sfa, but even more reason to tear up any existing agreements. You are spot on, they will go on about keeping the money in football, but really murrayfield should be used in this case. Personally, I'd never have any semi finals at Hampden, just devalues it. Simple solution, draw up every conceivable fixture and pre determine where any semi between those clubs would be played. E.g. Saints v United to be played at East End park, Aberdeen v Kiillie at Tynecastle etc. Rangers v Celtic should be toss of a coin. Takes out the nonsense like this week. Add to that, no club should be allowed to play a fixture where there is no scheduled public transport that would allow for fans to get there for kick off. No exceptions. Final rant, toss of coin for whichever end at hampden each set of fans get and make the journalists and suits sit in row a right behind the goals.
  16. TheYellowBox

    Is Scottish Football truly incompetent?

    It's utter utter bollocks to be honest. Aside from the obvious issue of 4 sets of fans that aren't exactly fond of each other all being in the same city on the same day, not to mention crossing paths at train and service station etc, the fact that it now emerges that any game involving the OF is contractually obliged to be played at Hampden is a disgrace. It literally is one set of rules for them and a different one for the rest. The Rangers and Celtic ends at hampden too boils my piss. Do the folk in charge really think this is all acceptable to fans? Massive changes needed.
  17. TheYellowBox

    Accounts 17-18

    Shows how much we are dependent on some of the away crowds. Suspect the core saints support doesn't vary much. Better football will help, but perversely, the only way I can see a big increase in our home support is a crisis. It's all too comfortable for Saints supporters. Not that I want it, but if we had an administration or such like, a lot of the fans would 're engage' to save the club, much like, Hearts, Dundee and Motherwell. We still have a decent support, just a lot don't attend games as regularly. Pretty sure all of us could name a dozen or so saints supporters who still follow the club, but rarely attend games, for all sorts of valid and understandable reasons.
  18. TheYellowBox

    Player Contracts + Transfers

    If we could somehow get Wright, Swanson, Kennedy and Sougall all to fit into the same side feeding Watt, that would be an incredible attacking line up! Every one of them real talents who could change a game in an instant. That would be a nightmare for any defence in our league to defend against!
  19. TheYellowBox

    Jason Kerr

    I'd say for Clark to get a call up at saints, there will need to be a series of call offs ahead of him. Archer, Gordon, McGregor and Marshall are all ahead in McLeish's eyes, but a couple of them get injured and he's in with a shout. Would be foolish to call up bain ahead of him if he is backup to Gordon. Clarks chance was last season when he got a run in the team and Hamilton got called up. If Mannus hasn't got his place back, he might have made a squad.
  20. TheYellowBox

    Jason Kerr

    Agree, I think they are capable, but will not get capped.
  21. TheYellowBox

    Jason Kerr

    Hmm, I see your point, but I don't think he is ahead of McKenna or Souttar certainly. Not to mention Liam Lindsay or David Bates who are both good young defenders. Kerr just needs to keep on developing. Let's not forget, he's had less than half a season being semi regular in the top flight and Gordon even less. Hendry baffles me, he's definitely not international class and his inclusion is 100% due to who he plays for. If Kerr continues to perform to a high level for the whole season and doesn't get a look in for friendlies, then I think we could argue that he is being overlooked for who he plays for. If like to think Clark, Kerr and Watt are all capable of being in and around the national set up in the near future.
  22. TheYellowBox

    Saints vs Dundee 25/08/18

    He managed to keep himself onside...Just! Was actually a similar one in the first half where he was off and Alston held on until he came back onside. First 40 mins I thought dundee looked ok, but with no real end product, but after that we controlled the game, albeit without the ball for a lot of the time, sounds odd, but we just let them knock it about in the knowledge they wouldn't hurt us. Liam was good and Alston is playing like the player I thought we'd be getting a couple of years ago. Tony Watt though, could easily get frustrated at times, but he doesn't, just sticks in and gets on with it and took his goal really well. I like that he just shoots, even when it looks like it's not the best option. A proper strikers striker. Really looks the part. Wright was quiet, but what I did notice is that he puts a shift in defensively when needed. Couple of decent defensive tackles and covered back in 2nd a couple of times when Foster drifted forward. I think we'll see games when he is on fire and when Kennedy is quiet and vice versa. I think bar maybe the number 10 role, Tommy has found his best starting 11.
  23. TheYellowBox

    Car Park

    It's got a total clusterfcuk written all over it. Aside from the traffic mismanagement from the hibs game, the fact that it will be a midweek game means fans will be arriving late anyway and all within a more condensed timeframe. The sensible solution would be to either, open the gate at the new road and or allow busses to be parked on the coned off half off the road and allow the fans to walk through the gate. Game like it to be on TV, so a delayed kick off would be embarrassing for the club and the council, so you'd assume they'd be getting it all in place. Also, the really obvious solution to the road problem would be for the police to turn off the traffic lights and have signs on the Crieff road directing all non football traffic either along the dunkeld road or through tulloch.
  24. TheYellowBox

    Celtic Allocation for Betfred Cup

    Give them the normal. I get the idea of maximising the cash, but for me, I'd take every advantage we have, however small it may be. Also, to give up so much of the stadium for cash just makes us look diddies. Imagine being a saints player and walking out to your home stadium full of away fans? Would knock you down straight off for that game, but also would just create an impression on players and everyone out with the club of us being tight and amateur for subsequent games. I'd rather 3000 empty seats rather than an extra 3000 Celtic fans. We all hated the days we gave them 3 stands, I certainly did.
  25. TheYellowBox

    Car Park

    Agree, surely a lot of the problems could have been sorted with some traffic police overriding the lights at the new junction keeping traffic flowing into the ground. Once the road is fully open, the new a9 slip will connect to the old slip and into McD, plus the crieff road will be much less busy. I see a lot of hibs fans used the crematorium over flow car park, is that something that will be open in the future?